The Smiler versus Saw the ride

[cjbrandy]

Which one of these Merlin Gerstlauer coasters is your favorite?

The Smiler
Pros: Long ride duration and breaks the inversion world record with 14
Cons: It can be very rattly if you get a bad train and it isn't very intense (in my opinion)

Saw the ride
Pros: Great indoor section, fairly intense and has some good airtime moments
Cons: Some people find it rough in places

 

[ATTACKHAMMER]

The Smiler. Saw is more vile.

 

[CookieCoasters]

The Smiler. Saw is more vile.

+1

 

[Hutch]

Saw's indoor portion is great, but I'd rather ride Smiler for it's airtime hills and first inversion. Saw does have some alright moments outside, but most of it is a bit forgettable and can be a bit rough. I did find Smiler intense too.

Both are pretty close in my lineup though, but Smiler edges.

 

[Rachel]

I had a really good ride on the Smiler so i'll go for that. Saw is good until it goes outside.